With disc brake bikes becoming more popular in cycling, rim widths aren't limited by brake calipers anymore which presents an opportunity to explore whether wider rims can be made faster by investigating aerodynamic theory. This blog explores the theory, and why we decided to introduce our Wide+, disc specific range.
When it comes to wheel Aerodynamics, there are lots of factors to consider in order to get a slick, wind-cheating, slippy wheel set and although it is well known deeper section profiles are more aerodynamic than shallower box section rims, one area is often overlooked is the relationship between the tyre and rim. But how important is it?
The Leading Edge, and what's behind it...
It'll come as no surprise that it's the tyre (leading edge) that starts the aerodynamic process when you're riding a bike, and how this interacts with the rim is crucial for air flow over a wheel system.
For wheel aerodynamics, the accepted theory to follow is that of the National Advisory Committee for Aeronatics (NACA) for aerofoils, and Image 1 illustrates how a NACA profile looks; not too dissimilar to an airplane wing, unsurprisingly.
NACA outline several key aspects for aerodynamics; but there's one very crucial area to consider that directly affects the aerodynamic performance of wheel systems - the widest point of an aerofoil should be about 33% from the leading edge to allow smooth airflow. This is known as the chord line.
Image 1 - Illustration of NACA Aerofoil Profile showing chord line ~33% from leading edge
As cyclists, understanding how this shape affects wheel performance is quite important if you want aerodynamic gains. For most of us that run aero wheels, the widest cross-sectional point is usually the tyre which is right at the leading edge, nowhere near the 33% chord line required for smooth airflow.
When this is the case, airflow does not follow a natural NACA profile. Rather than flow naturally over the tyre/rim, disrupted air gets pulled towards the rim, effectively 'clinging' to the surface until it's thrown from the trialing edge; as illustrated in Image 2. Ultimately, by having a tyre wider than the rim, the tyre now plays the dominant role in aerodynamics, and the rim now plays a more diminished role = Increased drag, less speed.
Image 2 - Aerodynamic drag illustration when tyre is wider than rim
*red arrows illustrate drag caused by having the tyre as the widest cross-sectional point on a deep section rim.
The Solution: Reduce tyre width, or Increase rim width
I'm sure you have figured it out already but for a wheel system to have improved aerodynamics, there are 2 things we can do; (i) reduce the size of tyre so it's narrower than the rim, or (ii) increase the width of rim so the widest point is closer to the chord line.
For point (i), this isn't an option for many as wider tyres are; well, really good at everything - increased handling, comfort, traction, stability. volume etc.
For this reason, we started our Wide+ project to explore whether we could increase rim width to offer a more aerodynamic profile that conformed to NACA.
Scribe Wide+ Models (60mm, 50mm, 42mm and 32mm)
For our Wide+ project, we decided to use a 25mm tyre as this is one of the most popular tyre sizes used today. Our goal was to work backwards to bring models to market that fitted a 25mm tyre (at least), but still allow the wheel system to have improved aerodynamics.
For our project, we used Schwalbe Pro One 25mm tyre which when inflated to 100psi on 21mm internal width, total tyre width comes up ~29mm. With this internal + our standard key dimensions; 1.5mm hooks + reinforced 3mm side walls, we had an outer rim width of 30mm.
Thus, by simply running a 25mm tyre on our Wide+ models, the leading edge (the tyre) comes up narrower than the widest point of the rim, which subsequently allows the rim to play the dominant role in aerodynamics, whereby; air will flow more efficiently over the wheel system - pushing drag to the trailing edge, as illustrated in image 3.
Image 3 - Illustration of how aerodynamic drag is moved by having a wider, more elliptical rim profile: Wide+ 42mm (1,422g) Disc shown
*Scribe Wide+ 42mm Disc with 21mm internal and 30mm external
What about Yaw (wind) angles?
For the Scribe Wide+ options, the trailing edge cross section is truncated in design to allow for a wide variety of yaw angles (Yaw refers to the apparent angle of wind in relation to the direction of wheel). On a flat body rim profiles, air flow separates early on the opposing side which creates a large wake, and therefore increases drag. This also reduces wheel stability and illustrated in Image 4.
Image 4 - Air flow illustration of traditional deep section flat body.
For the Scribe Wide+ range, our rims are Truncated (Elliptical) and the trailing edge profile helps keep air flow closer on opposite side reduces drag, and offers increased wheel stability, as illustrated in image 5.
Image 5 - Air flow illustration for Scribe Wide+ 42mm (1,422g) Disc with elliptical profile
If you have any questions on our range, or would like to know more about our product, please don't hesitate to contact us at email@example.com
*Video illustrating Wide+ 32mm Disc with thin 23mm tyre going through 4 times ISO standard (3 million cobbles) to test for strength.
Scribe Development Programme - Sign up to have an input!
At Scribe, we're constantly testing, challenging and obsessing over the smallest of details to make sure we bring the absolute best product possible to market. However, we do this for you, the riders, and we would like to invite you to be a part of our journey.
We have access to some of the best cycling specific product engineers in the world and we would love to know what you think we should work on. We want to hear the the mad, the wonderful and even the wacky ideas from real life riders. If we think there is a feasible product for others in the market; we'll do it! Sign up to get involved.